How does Cutting Force and Cutting Power Affect Machining Process?

Ever wondered what truly dictates the final quality and cost of your CNC machined parts? Beyond the obvious factors, an invisible force is at play: cutting force. Understanding and controlling this, along with cutting power, is the secret to achieving precision, efficiency, and optimal results. This guide breaks down these critical concepts, empowering you to make smarter design and manufacturing choices.

What is Cutting Force?

During machining, the tool induces elastic and plastic deformation in three components: the workpiece's surface metal, chips, and the machined area. These deformations generate opposing forces acting on the rake face and flank face respectively. As chips flow along the rake face and relative motion occurs between the tool and workpiece, frictional forces also develop across both surfaces. The resultant force acting on the cutting tool is defined as the total cutting force F, commonly referred to as the cutting force.

Since the force F is influenced by multiple factors, its magnitude and direction are not fixed. To facilitate the analysis of cutting force effects and measurement of its magnitude, the total cutting force F is typically decomposed into three mutually perpendicular cutting components, as illustrated in Figure 1-3-9.

1.The cutting force Fc is the component of the total cutting force in the primary motion direction. As a result, it is perpendicular to the base plane and represents the largest cutting component. It accounts for 95% to 99% of the total power consumption. This force serves as a key parameter for computer-controlled machine power, tool verification, and fixture strength/stiffness assessment.

2.The backward force Fp, representing the component of the total cutting force along the cutting depth direction, acts within the base plane perpendicular to the feed direction. Acting in the direction of the weakest system stiffness (machine-tool-fixture-workpiece-tool), this force is prone to causing vibrations and machining errors. It serves as a fundamental parameter for designing and verifying system stiffness and machining accuracy.

Figure 1-3-9 Decomposition of Cutting Forces

3. Feed force F" is the component of the total cutting force acting along the feed direction. This force, aligned with the feed direction in the base plane, is applied to the machine tool's feed mechanism. It serves as a key parameter for calculating and verifying the power, strength, and rigidity of the machine tool's feed system.

As shown in Figures 1-3-9, the relationship between the total cutting force F and its three component forces is

What is Cutting Power ?

The power consumed during the cutting process is termed cutting power pm. This power equals the sum of the power consumed by the cutting force Fc and the feed force Ff. Since the counterforce Fp does not displace, it consumes no power. Therefore, the cutting power (W) is

where Fc is the cutting force (N);

oc — Cutting speed (m/s); F" — Feed force (N);

o' —feed rate (mm/s).

Generally, the power consumed by F₁ (accounting for approximately 1% to 2% of Pm) is significantly lower than that of Fc. Therefore, Equation (1-3-2) can be simplified as

After calculating pm using the above formula, to determine the power pE of the machine tool motor, divide pm by the transmission efficiency ηm of the machine tool (typically ηm = 0.75 to 0.85), i.e.

What is Empirical Formula for Cutting Force?

At present, the empirical formula for calculating cutting force in production can be divided into two categories: one is the exponential formula, the other is the calculation according to unit cutting force.

(1)The exponential formula for calculating cutting force has been widely adopted in practical production, expressed as

Oblique cutting refers to the cutting process where the tool's main cutting edge has an inclination angle λs=0, meaning the cutting edge does not form a right angle with the direction of cutting speed. Figure 1-3-7b illustrates the scenario during oblique planing, which also falls under the category of free cutting. In oblique cutting, the direction of chip flow on the main cutting edge will deviate from its normal

Figure 1-3-7 Right cutting and oblique cutting

The coefficients CFc, CFp, and CF" are determined by the workpiece material and cutting parameters.

XFc、YFc、nFc、XFp、YFp、nFp

XF, YF, and nF represent the exponents of cutting depth ap, feed rate f, and cutting speed oc in the three component force formulas respectively.

In the formulas for KFc, KFp, and KF, the actual processing conditions differ from those used to derive empirical formulas.

When they are not consistent, the product of various factors to the correction factor of cutting component force.

Let KMF, KYOF, KkrF, KλSF, KrεF, and KTF represent the mechanical properties of the workpiece, the tool's rake angle, principal rake angle, cutting edge inclination angle, tip radius, and the correction coefficients for cutting forces under varying durability conditions, respectively. Denote KF as the combined coefficients KFc, KFp, and KFγ.

KF = KMFKYOFKkrFKλSFKrεFKTF                                                                                          (1 - 3 - 6)

The values of the coefficients and indices in equations (1-3-5), as well as the values of the modified coefficients in equations (1-3-6) under various cutting conditions, can be found in the relevant chapters of this book.

  • Calculation of cutting force and power using unit cutting force

 Unit cutting force p is the cutting force (N) per unit cutting layer nominal cross-sectional area (m2), so

In the formula, Fc is the cutting force (N);

AD — Nominal cross-sectional area of the cutting layer (m²);

bD — nominal width of the cutting layer (mm);

hD — nominal thickness of the cutting layer (mm);

Ap-cutting depth (mm);

『 — Feed (mm/r).

The unit cutting power pc is the power required to remove a unit volume of material per unit time (W/(m³/s)). Therefore

Q = 10 - 6ocap『

where Q is the material removal rate (m³/s);

oc-Cutting speed (m/s);

Pc — Cutting power (W);

Pc = Fcoc ≈ 10 - 6pap『oc                                                                                                           (1 - 3 - 10)

Substituting Q and Pc into equations (1-3-9) yields

Therefore, if the unit cutting force p is known, the cutting force Fc can be calculated by Equation (1-3-8), and the cutting power Pc can be calculated by Equation (1-3-10).

The specific values of unit cutting forces can be found in relevant literature. Table 1-3-1 shows the unit cutting forces and unit cutting power of several commonly used materials cut by cemented carbide external turning tools.

Table 1-3-1: Common Metal Cutting Performance of Cemented Carbide External Turning Tools

unit cutting force and unit cutting power

Workpiece materialUnit cutting force p / (N/mm²) 『 = 0. 3mm/r  Unit cutting power pc / (kW/ (mm3/S))   『 = 0. 3mm/rexperiment condition 
 classnamethe name of a shopManufacturing and heat treatment statushardness HBsTool geometry parametersCutting parameters range 
                                     steelfree cutting steelY40Mnhot rolling20216681668 × 10 - 6  Yo = 15o kr = 75o λs = 0o bY1 = 0 Front blade surface with chip groove                              vc   =  90  ~ 150m/min ap    =  1  ~ 5mm 『   =  0.1  ~ 0.5mm/r 
          Carbon Knot Steel structure, alloy junction Steel sectionQ235 - A    Hot rolled or normalized134 ~ 13718841884 × 10 - 6 
45187    1962    1962 × 10 - 6 
40cr212 
40MnB207 ~ 212 
38crMoAlA241 ~ 269 
45Tempering (quenching and high Tempering)229  23052305 × 10 - 6Yo  = 15o,kr = 75o,λs  = 0o bY1  = 0. 1 ~ 0. 15mm Yo1 = -20° before the blade surface has a chip groove 
40cr285 
38crsi29221972197 × 10 - 6 
  45Tempering (quenching and low Tempering)44 (HRc)  2649  2649 × 10 - 6 
          tool steel60si2Mn hot rolling269 ~ 27719621962 × 10 - 6      Yo = 15o kr = 75o λs = 0o bYl  = 0 Front blade surface with chip groove 
T10A        anneal189        2060        2060 × 10 - 6 
9crsi223 ~ 228 
cr12223 ~ 228 
cr12MoV262 
3cr2W8248 
5crNiMo209 
W18cr4V235 ~ 241 
 ball bearing steelGcr15 anneal19621092109 × 10 - 6 
     stainless steel    1cr18Ni9Ti    quenching and tempering    170 ~ 179    2453    2453 × 10 - 6Angle: 20°, Radius: 75°, Surface: λs = 0°, bY1 = 0, front blade surface with chip groove 
Workpiece materialUnit cutting force p / (N/mm2) 『 = 0. 3mm/r  Unit cutting power pc / (kW/ (mm3/S))     『 = 0. 3mm/rexperiment condition
 classname the name of a shopManufacturing, heat treatment statushardness HBSTool geometryCutting parameters range
 iron casting  gray pig iron  HT200             anneal  170  1118  1118 × 10 - 6  yo  = 15o,kr   = 75o,λs  = 0o,by1  = 0, Flat cutting surface, no chip groove      vc  = 1. 17 ~ 1.42m/s (70 ~ 85m/ min), ap    =  2  ~ 10mm,『  = 0. 1         0. 1         ~ 0. 5mm/r
  nodular cast iron  QT450 - 10  170 ~ 207  1413  1413 × 10 - 6
    malleable cast-iron    KTH300 - 06    170    1344    1344 × 10 - 6yo = 15o, kr = 75o, λs = 0o, by1 = 0, front blade surface with chip groove
      chilled cast iron      Roller for      case harden      52 ~ 55 (HRC)3434 〔『 = 0 . 8〕3434 × 10 - 6  yo = 0o,kr  = 12 ~ 14o,λs = 0o,B"1 = 0, Flat cutting surface, no chip groove  vc                  =                  vc                  = 0. 117m/s (7m/min), ap    =  1  ~ 3mm,『 = 0.1 ~ 1.2mm/r
3139 〔『  = 1〕3139 × 10 - 6
2845 〔『 = 1 . 2〕2845 × 10 - 6
 alufer    cast aluminium alloy    ZL110    cast-on outwell    45814.2 〔yo = 15o〕814.2 × 10 - 6    yo     =   15o, 25o , kr     = 75o,λs  = 0o, by1 = 0, Flat cutting surface, no chip flute    vc  =  180m/ min, ap    =  2  ~ 6mm,『    = 0. 1         0. 1         ~ 0. 5mm/r
706.3 〔yo  = 25o〕706.3 × 10 - 6
    hard aluminum alloys    ZA12  Tempering and aging    107833.9 〔yo  = 15o〕833.9 × 10 - 6
765.2 〔yo  = 25o〕765.2 × 10 - 6
Copper and copper alloysyellow metalH62 cold-drawing8014221422 × 10 - 6  Angle: 15°, Radius: 75°, Surface: λs = 0°, By1: 0°, Flat front blade surface, No chip flute  vc = 1.83m/s (    110m/ min),ap  = 2 ~ 6mm,『 = 0.1          0.1          ~ 0.5mm/r
Workpiece materialCutting force per unit p (N/mm²) 『 = 0 . 3mm/r  Unit cutting power pc / (kW/ (mm3/S))   『 = 0 . 3mm/rexperiment condition 
 classname the name of a shopManufacturing, heat treatment statushardness HBSTool geometryCutting parameters range 
      molybdenum      Pure molybdenum       powder metallurgy      109      2413      2413 × 10— 6Yo = 20o,kr  = 90o,λs  = 0o,bY1 = 0. 15mm,Yo1 =  — 5o, Front cutting edge with chip groove  vc = 40m/min ap = 1 ~ 5mm, 『   =  0.1  ~ 0.4mm/r 
Note: 1. For cutting various steels, use YT15 blades; for stainless steel, cast iron, copper, and aluminum, use YG8 or YG6 blades; for molybdenum, use YW2 blades.
2. No cutting fluid.

What are the Factors affecting cutting force?

Table 1-3-2 Factors affecting cutting force

 influencing factorexplain
    Workpiece materialThe higher the strength and hardness of the workpiece material, the greater the cutting force required. Materials with a higher tendency to work hard during machining will require more force. The addition of elements like sulfur and lead to the workpiece (such as in machinable steel) reduces cutting force. When machining brittle materials like cast iron, the minimal plastic deformation in the cutting layer results in low work hardening, leading to less friction between the fragmented chips and the tool face, thus reducing cutting force. Additionally, variations in heat treatment conditions and microstructural composition of the same material can also influence cutting force levels.
Cutting depth ap, feed rateAs the cutting depth (ap) and feed rate (f) increase, the deformation resistance and friction force rise, consequently increasing the cutting force. However, their impacts on the cutting force differ: typically, doubling the cutting depth (ap) doubles the cutting force, whereas doubling the feed rate (f) only increases it by 68% to 86%.
      cutting speed vcWhen machining plastic metals, the effect of cutting speed vc on cutting forces exhibits a wavelike pattern. At low speeds (vc <50 m/min), as vc increases, the chip mound gradually grows, causing the tool's effective rake angle to progressively increase and resulting in a gradual decrease in cutting force. When vc continues to rise, the chip mound diminishes and eventually disappears, leading to an increase in cutting force. Beyond 50 m/min, increased cutting speed raises temperatures and reduces frictional forces, causing the cutting force to decrease again. When cutting brittle metal, the plastic deformation is very small, and the friction between chip and rake face is also small, so vc has little influence on cutting force
  anterior angle YoA larger tool rake angle reduces deformation in the cutting layer, thereby decreasing cutting forces. The influence of rake angle on cutting forces diminishes with increasing cutting speed, as elevated temperatures during high-speed machining reduce friction, work hardening, and plastic deformation. When machining brittle metals like cast iron, the effect of rake angle on cutting forces becomes less significant.
  tool cutting edge angle krWhen the nominal cross-sectional area of the cutting layer remains constant, an increase in kr leads to a greater nominal thickness and reduced deformation, consequently decreasing the cutting force Fc. However, when kr exceeds 60° to 75°, the increased radius of the cutting edge arc causes a slight rise in Fc due to its greater weight. As kr increases further, Fp decreases while F' rises significantly.
 tool cutting edge inclination angle λs,λs has no effect on Fc when it varies over a wide range (from-40°C to +40°C), but as λs decreases, Fp increases and F' decreases.
influencing factorexplain
Tip radius YεThe effect of Yε on Fc is small. When Yε increases, Fp will increase
cutter materialThe friction coefficient between the tool and the workpiece directly affects the cutting force. Under the same cutting conditions, the cutting force of high-speed steel tool is the largest, followed by cemented carbide, and the smallest is ceramic tool.
cutting fluidThe higher the lubrication performance of cutting fluid, the more obvious the reduction of cutting force
cutting-tool wearWhen the tool face is worn, the contact friction increases and the cutting force increases; when the tool face is worn to form a crescent-shaped depression, the cutting force decreases due to the increased rake angle

How to Measure the cutting force?

There are two primary methods for measuring cutting component forces. The first category involves indirect measurement techniques, such as attaching strain gauges to rolling bearing outer rings, using displacement meters to measure spindle or tool holder deformation, monitoring drive motor power consumption or slip rates, and measuring hydrostatic bearing pressure. These methods allow indirect determination of cutting force magnitude. The second category employs direct measurement methods, primarily utilizing force gauges. Common types include strain gauge and piezoelectric force gauges. Their working principle involves detecting deformation in the gauge's elastic components caused by cutting forces, or converting electrical charges generated by piezoelectric crystals to measure individual cutting component forces.

(1) Resistance strain gauge force gauge

This measuring instrument has the characteristics of high sensitivity, large range, can be used for static and dynamic measurement, and high measurement accuracy.

The resistive elements commonly used in measuring instruments are called strain gauges. Multiple strain gauges are tightly attached to different stress points on the elastic components of the measuring instrument, each connected to form an electrical bridge (see Figure 1-3-10). When subjected to cutting forces, the strain gauges deform along with the elastic components, altering their resistance values and disrupting the bridge's balance. This generates an output current proportional to the magnitude of the cutting force. After amplification and calibration, the values of the three-directional cutting component forces can be accurately measured.

Figure 1-3-10 Layout of eight-sided ring lathe force gauge and strain gauge

(2) Piezoelectric Force Gauge

This high-precision device features superior sensitivity, high rigidity, and excellent self-resonance frequency. It demonstrates outstanding linearity, strong interference resistance, and zero inertia, making it particularly suitable for dynamic force measurement and instantaneous force detection. However, its humidity sensitivity is a notable limitation. When continuously measuring stable or minimally varying forces, the system may experience zero-point drift caused by charge leakage, which can compromise measurement accuracy.

Piezoelectric force gauges operate through the piezoelectric effect in quartz crystals or ceramic materials. When subjected to force, these components generate surface charges whose magnitude is proportional to the applied pressure, regardless of the crystal's size. A charge amplifier converts these charges into corresponding voltage parameters, enabling precise measurement of force magnitude (see Figure 1-3-11a).

A multi-directional force sensor (see Figure 1-3-11b) is formed by mechanically arranging several quartz components in sequence. When force is applied to the sensor, it acts on the quartz plates. Due to the different cutting directions of the quartz crystals, the sensitivity varies in each force direction, thus enabling the separate measurement of each cutting component force.

Figure 1-3-11 Piezoelectric sensor

a) Unidirectional force sensor and force measurement system b) Triaxial force sensor

1-Piezoelectric sensor 2-Charge amplifier 3-Peak voltmeter 4-Cathode ray oscilloscope

2-Light oscilloscope 6-PTFE sleeve 7-Chip 8-Cover 9-Electron beam weld 10-Base

Conclusion

In summary, cutting force and power are fundamental to the machining process. They directly impact tool life, surface finish, and part accuracy. By understanding how materials, tool geometry, and cutting parameters influence these forces, we can optimize for higher quality, greater efficiency, and reduced costs in every project.

//]]>